Jim Rutherford Under Fire as Rick Tocchet Opens Door to Western Conference Return: Canucks Fans Left Fuming
A storm is brewing in Vancouver as new revelations surface about former Canucks head coach Rick Tocchet and his willingness to explore coaching opportunities across the NHL, including in the Western Conference—a twist that directly contradicts earlier claims made by Canucks President Jim Rutherford. The development has sparked a wave of criticism and concern about leadership transparency and decision-making at the top of the Canucks organization.
According to insider Rick Dhaliwal, Tocchet is no longer limiting his options to the East Coast. Appearing on Donnie and Dhali – The Team, Dhaliwal made it clear that Tocchet has broadened his coaching search and is now open to listening to offers from any NHL club, including teams based in the West.
“I’m under the impression that Tocchet will listen to all teams—Seattle, Anaheim, even Los Angeles if there’s a change—not just East Coast franchises,” Dhaliwal said.
The remarks caught fire quickly among NHL media circles, especially since they contrast directly with Rutherford’s prior assertion that Tocchet was only eyeing roles on the East Coast. That claim, once thought to explain his departure in a way that made sense geographically and personally, now appears increasingly shaky.
Adding fuel to the fire, Frank Seravalli of Daily Faceoff dropped a bombshell on Halford and Brough during a segment on Sportsnet 650. According to Seravalli, it’s a near certainty that Tocchet has already held meetings with the Seattle Kraken. While nothing has been confirmed officially, the strong indication that Seattle may already be in discussions with the former Canucks coach has inflamed tensions.
The Kraken, who recently parted ways with Dan Bylsma after just one season at the helm, are actively searching for a new leader. Bylsma’s departure followed a disappointing campaign in which the Kraken missed the playoffs for the second consecutive year. That vacancy now potentially sets the stage for one of the more awkward storylines in recent NHL history: Tocchet going from Vancouver to a divisional rival.
Tocchet’s exit from Vancouver was confirmed by the team earlier this year after what was widely viewed as a chaotic and underwhelming 2024–25 season. Despite high hopes and playoff aspirations, the Canucks fell short, and rumors of internal dysfunction began swirling long before the season ended.
The announcement of Tocchet’s departure sparked immediate speculation about his next move, especially given his strong reputation as a bench boss. With a Stanley Cup pedigree and years of experience behind the bench, Tocchet quickly became one of the most talked-about names in coaching circles.
However, the twist that he might end up staying in the Western Conference—especially with a Pacific Division rival like Seattle—has left a bitter taste for many in Vancouver. It’s not just the optics of it; it’s the perceived betrayal of both fan trust and internal consistency.
Dhaliwal didn’t hold back his criticism, describing the prospect of Tocchet joining a nearby rival as an unthinkable scenario. “It’s not good,” he said. “If he ends up in Seattle—my goodness—that’s in your own division. That’s like trading Thatcher Demko within your division. You don’t let a coach walk out of your organization and straight into a team that competes against you regularly. The optics are just atrocious.”
On social media, fans and pundits echoed Dhaliwal’s sentiments. Popular hockey commentator Taj took to X (formerly Twitter) and called the situation a “comedy,” lamenting how the Canucks might have mishandled one of their most valuable assets.
The broader issue now centers on the credibility of Jim Rutherford’s statements and whether fans and media can take future comments from the Canucks front office at face value. If Rutherford insisted that Tocchet was only interested in East Coast jobs—either to smooth over his departure or deflect scrutiny—and that turns out to be false, it calls into question the transparency and strategy of the organization’s leadership.
Further complicating matters, Tocchet is expected to be one of the most sought-after coaches this offseason. In addition to the Kraken, teams like the Anaheim Ducks, Pittsburgh Penguins, Philadelphia Flyers, and Chicago Blackhawks are all reportedly in the market for a new head coach. Each of these franchises presents unique opportunities and challenges, but if Tocchet ends up with any Western team—especially one in the Pacific—it’s going to remain a sore spot for Canucks supporters.
Internally, the Canucks have been trying to reset the narrative after a turbulent season. The decision to move on from Tocchet was framed as a mutual parting meant to allow both sides to pursue fresh starts. But with these new developments, it’s clear the separation may have been more complicated than initially suggested.
For now, all eyes are on Tocchet and where he lands. But perhaps more importantly, Canucks fans are watching their own front office just as closely. The contrast between what was said publicly and what’s unfolding behind the scenes has reignited calls for more accountability and strategic clarity.
As the offseason heats up, the Canucks aren’t just trying to find a new head coach—they’re also trying to hold onto the trust of their fanbase. Whether they succeed may depend less on who stands behind the bench next season and more on whether they can prove they’re truly in control of the franchise’s direction.
—
