Could Chiles and Marsh Exit MSU If Another Losing Season Looms?
The looming question for Michigan State University (MSU) football fans as the new season approaches isn’t just whether the team can bounce back from a disappointing campaign—it’s whether key players like quarterback Sam Leavitt Chiles and wide receiver Jaron Marsh will stick around if things don’t improve. As MSU continues to struggle for consistency and identity in the increasingly competitive Big Ten, the pressure is mounting, not just on the coaching staff but on the program’s top talents. If MSU falters again, a player exodus—especially of stars like Chiles and Marsh—could become a very real scenario.
Now, let’s shift our focus to another storyline brewing in the Big Ten, where the spotlight is beginning to shine on a quarterback hoping to redefine his narrative: Wisconsin’s Billy Edwards Jr.
Billy Edwards Jr.: Poised to Rise in the Big Ten QB Rankings?
As Big Ten teams begin to gear up for what’s expected to be one of the most competitive seasons in recent memory, the conversation surrounding top quarterbacks is already in full swing. But one name noticeably missing from most preseason Top 10 lists is Wisconsin Badgers transfer Billy Edwards Jr.
Once a highly regarded quarterback at Maryland, Edwards saw his stock fall sharply following the Terrapins’ late-season collapse. Much of that decline was attributed to coaching instability, locker room discord, and an offensive system that never fully played to Edwards’ strengths. Now, after transferring to Wisconsin, Edwards has a fresh opportunity—but he’ll need to prove himself all over again in a new environment.
What makes Edwards’ situation unique is that he doesn’t have to light up the stat sheet to earn respect. Unlike quarterbacks expected to deliver Heisman-caliber performances or post 4,000-yard seasons, Edwards’ path to recognition is rooted in efficiency and control.
The Role of Experience
One of Edwards’ biggest assets coming into this season is his experience. Having already played in the Big Ten under high-pressure situations, he’s seen the kind of defenses he’ll face and knows what it takes to operate in fast-paced, physical games. That gives him a critical advantage over younger, less tested quarterbacks who may be higher on talent but lower on in-game composure.
Wisconsin offensive coordinator Jeff Grimes isn’t expecting Edwards to be the next Caleb Williams. Instead, he’s building an offense that capitalizes on Edwards’ ability to manage the game, avoid turnovers, and keep the chains moving.
If Edwards can stay poised in the pocket, make smart decisions, and execute Grimes’ game plan consistently, he can carve out a place for himself among the conference’s top quarterbacks—even without jaw-dropping stats.
A System Built for Balance
Grimes’ offensive scheme is predicated on balance—establishing a strong run game while taking high-percentage shots through the air. That’s a formula tailor-made for someone like Edwards, who has shown an ability to make accurate throws under pressure and protect the football.
At Maryland, Edwards occasionally struggled in a system that demanded quick deep throws with minimal protection. In contrast, the Wisconsin offense is designed to minimize risk and maximize output through strategic play-calling. If Edwards can operate within those guardrails and deliver when called upon, he can quietly emerge as a top-tier performer.
It’s also worth noting that Wisconsin’s offensive line—traditionally one of the strongest in the Big Ten—gives Edwards a level of protection he lacked in previous seasons. That security will give him the opportunity to make better reads and avoid the hurried throws that often lead to interceptions.
Leadership Matters
One of the intangible factors working in Edwards’ favor is his leadership. According to teammates and coaches, he’s already established himself as a vocal presence in the locker room and a steadying influence on the field. That’s a significant quality, especially for a team looking to regain its footing after a rocky season.
While statistics can often tell a part of the story, leadership is the kind of attribute that elevates an entire team’s performance. Edwards’ ability to rally teammates, inspire confidence, and manage the huddle could make him the kind of field general Wisconsin needs this season.
Low Expectations Could Be an Advantage
There’s something to be said for flying under the radar. With most of the media attention going to quarterbacks at Ohio State, Michigan, and Penn State, Edwards enters the season with relatively low expectations from outside observers. That lack of pressure could work to his advantage, allowing him to grow into the role without the constant scrutiny faced by higher-profile players.
It also presents Edwards with an opportunity to surprise people. If he can guide the Badgers to a strong start and keep them competitive in conference play, it won’t be long before his name starts climbing those rankings.
A Real Shot at the Top 10?
So, what exactly does Billy Edwards Jr. need to do to crack the Big Ten’s Top 10 quarterback list? He doesn’t need to lead the conference in passing yards. He doesn’t need to be the flashiest player on the field. What he does need is to run the offense efficiently, minimize mistakes, and win games.
If he can do that—and there’s every reason to believe he can given the tools around him—Edwards could be one of the most improved and impactful transfers in the league.
In the end, football remains a results-driven game. If Wisconsin wins and Edwards plays well, his place in the conversation will take care of itself.
Big Ten Quarterback Landscape
The Big Ten is teeming with talent at quarterback this year. From proven stars to rising prospects, the battle for supremacy will be fierce. That said, not every QB needs to be a stat-sheet stuffer. Billy Edwards Jr. represents the kind of player who can make a major impact through smart play, veteran leadership, and a commitment to doing the little things right.
As fans and analysts continue to debate the conference’s quarterback hierarchy, don’t be surprised if Edwards emerges as a dark horse contender for one of those coveted Top 10 spots.
He may not have started the season with hype, but if everything clicks in Madison, he could very well finish it as one of the Big Ten’s most reliable and respected quarterbacks.
