The Indianapolis Colts’ disappointing loss to the New York Giants in Week 17 has cast a shadow over general manager Chris Ballard’s future with the organization. Despite Ballard’s early success in Indianapolis, questions are mounting about his ability to guide the team back to contention, especially after missing the playoffs for the third consecutive season.
Colts’ Struggles in 2024
The Colts entered their Week 17 matchup against the 2-13 Giants with slim playoff hopes, only to be dealt a crushing 45-33 defeat. The Giants, who had not scored 30 points in a game all season, took advantage of a Colts defense that appeared unprepared. The loss marked a low point for Indianapolis, which now faces its fourth losing season in Ballard’s eight-year tenure.
Ballard’s Tenure: A Mixed Legacy
Chris Ballard, hired as the Colts’ GM in January 2017, initially built a strong reputation by assembling talented draft classes, most notably in 2018. That class included All-Pro guard Quenton Nelson, linebacker Shaquille Leonard, and key contributors like offensive tackle Braden Smith. However, the Colts’ trajectory shifted dramatically following quarterback Andrew Luck’s sudden retirement in 2019.
Since then, Ballard has struggled to find a long-term solution at quarterback, cycling through veterans like Philip Rivers, Carson Wentz, and Matt Ryan before drafting Anthony Richardson with the fourth overall pick in 2023. Injuries and inconsistent play have limited Richardson’s impact, leaving the team without a clear franchise quarterback.
Under Ballard, the Colts have yet to win the AFC South, a glaring shortcoming compared to their division rivals. While Ballard has built strong individual units, such as the offensive line and defense in earlier seasons, the team’s overall performance has been inconsistent.
Criticism and Uncertain Future
NFL insiders, including ESPN’s Stephen Holder, report that Ballard’s job security is under scrutiny after the Giants’ loss. Despite some successes, the Colts’ inability to achieve sustained success or stability at quarterback raises concerns about the direction of the franchise.
Ballard’s decision-making in recent years, including high-profile trades and free-agent signings, has been criticized. The revolving door at quarterback has prevented the team from building long-term cohesion, while key injuries and declining performances from cornerstone players like Leonard have further hampered the team.
What’s Next for the Colts?
Owner Jim Irsay will face a critical decision regarding Ballard’s future. While Ballard has demonstrated an ability to identify talent, his track record in addressing the quarterback position and building a consistent contender leaves much to be desired.
If Ballard remains, the 2025 offseason will be pivotal. The Colts must decide whether to continue developing Richardson or pursue another veteran quarterback, along with addressing weaknesses on both sides of the ball. If a change is made, a new general manager could signal a fresh start for a franchise that has struggled to regain its footing since Luck’s retirement.
The Colts’ fanbase is growing restless, and after another lost season, the pressure is mounting for significant changes to restore the team’s competitiveness in the AFC.
